Recent Cases
LTA Claimholders Group v. LATAM Airlines Group S.A. (In re LATAM Airlines Group S.A.), ___F.4th___ (2d Cir. Dec. 14, 2022)
LTA Claimholders Group v. LATAM Airlines Group S.A. (In re LATAM Airlines Group S.A.), ___F.4th___ (2d Cir. Dec. 14, 2022), appeal 22-1940: Second Circuit Court of Appeal agrees with Ninth, Fifth and Third Circuits, that a claim is only “impaired” if a bankruptcy 13 or 11 plan changes that claims rights; and that an unsecured creditor of an insolvent debtor is not entitled to be paid post-petition interest by the debtor’s plan, where the plan treatment of that unsecured creditor’s claim is “unimpaired” Unimpaired, Unsecured Creditors Don’t Get Post-Petition Interest No “Circuit Split” occurred, because, because the Second Circuit agrees…
Avion Funding LLC v. GFS Industries LLC (In re GFS Industries LLC), 22-05052 (Bankr. W.D. Tex. Nov. 10, 2022)
Avion Funding LLC v. GFS Industries LLC (In re GFS Industries LLC), 22-05052 (Bankr. W.D. Tex. Nov. 10, 2022): discusses that there is a “split” (ie disagreement) among Judges as to whether or not a corporation that files Subchapter V of Chapter 11 bankruptcy case can be sued to hold a debt “nondischargeable”, pursuant to 11 USC 523(a)(2), (4) or (6), where the debt is a debt arising from debtor committing fraud, embezzlement, breach of fiducisary duty, or is a debt from debtor committing a “willful and malicious act” (except a Chapter 13 debtor can seek to discharge a “willful…
Masingale v. Muding (In re Masingale), ___BR___ (9th Cir. BAP 11/2/22), appeal 22-1016
Masingale v. Muding (In re Masingale), ___BR___ (9th Cir. BAP 11/2/22), appeal 22-1016; for publication 9th Cir BAP decision is important, because BAP rules that by claiming exemption of ‘100% of FMV’ of asset (usually homestead exemption, but could be something like stock) debtors keep postpetition appreciation in exempt assets. Note that for debtors in California, using California exemptions, this result is the result required by the amended California exemption law, which takes effect for bankruptcy cases filed after 1/21/23.
Tico Construction Co. v. Van Meter (In re Powell)
Tico Construction Co. v. Van Meter (In re Powell), ___BR___ (B.A.P. 9th Cir. Oct. 21, 2022), appeal number 22-1014.9th Cir BAP says debtor has absolute right to dismiss a ch13 case, even if debtor was not eligible to file ch13. I can see some possibilities this ruling could be abused by a debtor who wants the automatic stay, but does not want to be stuck in bankruptcy, so files a Chapter 13 case, knowing debtor is NOT eligible for chapter 13, then later dismisses the Chapter 13 case, after having the bankruptcy automatic stay protecting the debtor for as long…
Smart Capital Investments I LLC v. Hawkeye Entertainment LLC (In re Hawkeye Entertainment LLC), ___F.4th___ (9th Cir. Sept. 23, 2022) appeal no. 21-56264
A Cured Breach Still Invokes Section 365(b)(1)’s Landlord Protections, Ninth Circuit Court of appeals rules Adequate assurance of future performance may not be required if the debtor has already cured the breach of lease, the Ninth Circuit says. If there has ever been a breach of a lease of real property — even if it was cured or was not material — the landlord is still entitled to “adequate protection” or one of the other assurances laid out in Section 365(b)(1), according to the Ninth Circuit. However, “adequate assurance” may not be required if the breach has been cured or…
In re Klein, ___BR___ (US Bankruptcy Court D. Colo. Aug. 23, 2022) bky case No.17-19106: holds Debtor Retains Appreciation in Nonexempt Property Sold During Chapter 13
Judge Rosania answered a question left open by the Tenth Circuit in Barrera. Answering a question left open by the Tenth Circuit in Rodriguez v. Barrera (In re Barrera), 22 F.4th 1217 (10th Cir. Jan. 19, 2022), Bankruptcy Judge Joseph G. Rosania, Jr., of Denver decided that a chapter 13 debtor retains appreciation in the value of nonexempt property that the debtor owned on the filing date but sold in the course of the chapter 13 case. In Barrera, the Tenth Circuit held that nonexempt appreciation in the value of a home sold after confirmation of a chapter 13 plan…
In re Castleman
In re Castleman, (US District Court W.D. Wash. July 1, 2022), appeal to District Court from Bankruptcy Court, DC case no. 21-00829: US District Court Affirms that when a Chapter 13 Debtor’s bankruptcy case is converted from Chapter 13 to Chapter 7, that appreciation in the value of debtor’s residence/real property from when the Chapter 13 case was filed, onward, belongs to the Chapter 7 bankruptcy estate, not to the debtor; whereas if the debtor had remained in Chapter 13, the appreciation in the value of the residence/real property, during the Chapter 13 case, belongs to the Chapter 13 bankruptcy…
Stark v. Pryor (In re Stark), 20-4766 (E.D.N.Y. June 28, 2022): US District Court Judge Bars a “Short Sale”, Unless the bankruptcy debtor’s Homestead Exemption is paid in full
Reversing, a Long Island district judge credits value to a homeowner’s ability to delay foreclosure, taking a position contrary to a recent decision from a Ninth Circuit B.A.P. On an issue where the lower courts are split, a district judge on Long Island, N.Y., reversed the bankruptcy court by holding that a debtor is entitled to a homestead exemption in sale proceeds when the mortgage lender offers to buy the home and voluntarily takes a haircut designed to create an estate for unsecured creditors and the trustee’s commission. The debtor’s mortgage was long in default. After judgment of foreclosure, the…
MOAC Mall Holdings LLC v. Transform Holdco LLC (In re Sears Holdings Corp.) 20-1846 (US Supreme Court), and Bartenwerfer v. Buckley, 21-908 (US Supreme Court)
The US Supreme Court now has two bankruptcy cases on the calendar for argument in the term to begin in October, 2022. These are MOAC Mall Holdings LLC v. Transform Holdco LLC (In re Sears Holdings Corp.) 20-1846 (US Supreme Court), and Bartenwerfer v. Buckley, 21-908 (US Supreme Court). On 6/27/22, the US Supreme Court granted a petition for certiorari, ithe MOAC case, to decide whether the failure to obtain the stay of a sale approval order erects a jurisdictional bar to appeal under Section 363(m). The courts of appeals are split 6-2. Led by the Second Circuit, the minority…
Spark Factor Design Inc. v. Hjelmeset (In re Open Medicine Institute Inc.)
Spark Factor Design Inc. v. Hjelmeset (In re Open Medicine Institute Inc.), ___BR___ (B.A.P. 9th Cir. May 26, 2022), appeal no. 21-1233: Ninth Circuit BAP decision holds that a bankruptcy court does NOT always have to evaluate a settlement/proposed compromise as an 11 USC 363 sale, and NOT to require overbidding opportunity. If there are mutual claims, the Ninth Circuit BAP gives the court discretion not to evaluate a settlement as a sale. When considering approval of a compromise and settlement that includes a sale of estate property, the bankruptcy court sometimes has discretion not to evaluate the transaction as…